Sujit Choudhry is a former law clerk, university dean, and professor. Despite his long list of accolades, Sujit is best known for his time spent as a constitutional adviser. Sujit traveled the world, helping world leaders and setting up democratic constitutions. Sujit Choudhry advised world leaders on subjects such as official language policy, secession, and federalism, see constitutionaltransitions.org.
Sujit is also an author, providing his work to books and journals such as The Migration of Constitutional Ideas and Is Every ballot equal? In a recent effort contributed to Constitutional Democracies in Crisis? Sujit writes about a tweet from Eric Holder, Barrack Obama’s Attorney General. The tweet was published in late 2017.
The tweet defined the firing of Bob Mueller as an absolute red line. “If removed or meaningfully tampered with,” Eric Holder wrote. “There must be mass popular, peaceful support of both. The American people must be seen and heard,” he concluded.
On first glance it appears that Holder is calling for the people to not allow Trump to fire Mueller, but he clearly states there will be support from both sides. In the book, Sujit Choudhry breaks down his personal opinion on the tweet, but he also talks about the thought process of Eric Holder.
Choudhry’s chapter in Constitutional Democracies in Crisis? talks about two possible concepts that Holder could have been coming from (works.bepress.com).
The first possibility is a constitutional red line that is non-controversial and widely accepted by previous Presidents. This concept is based on what is allowed by the Constitution of the United States: Holder could have been saying that there are actual rules against a President firing a special investigation that is investigating the President.
The other concept that Holder could have been speaking about is civil unrest. He could have been merely stating that civilians are too involved with the investigation and neither side will buy the conclusion, no matter what is decided. If Trump fires Mueller, people could riot; If Mueller finds Trump guilty of a crime, people could riot. The red line could have been a symbol of the political divide in America.
Related Link: http://sujitchoudhry.com/